| Away | Home | Status | Links | |||
| Roanoke | 7 | No. 10 Lynchburg | 8 | Final | • * | BX RC P |
| Christopher Newport | 1 | No. 11 Salisbury | 5 | Final | • | BX |
| Spalding | 3 | No. 22 Webster | 4 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Grinnell | 14 | Illinois College | 19 | Final | • * | BX |
| Clarkson | 1 | Bard | 0 | Final - 7 innings | • * | |
| Washington and Lee | 2 | Virginia Wesleyan | 3 | Final - 12 innings | • * | BX |
| Mount Aloysius | 10 | Pitt-Bradford | 3 | Final | • * | BX |
| Grinnell | 5 | Illinois College | 2 | Final | • * | BX |
| Clarkson | 3 | Bard | 2 | Final - 9 innings | • * | |
| Washington and Lee | 9 | Virginia Wesleyan | 5 | Final | • * | BX |
| Mount Aloysius | 4 | Pitt-Bradford | 5 | Final | • * | BX |
| Northland | 4 | Carleton | 15 | Final | • | BX |
| Pacific Lutheran | 11 | Willamette | 5 | Final | • * | BX |