| Away | Home | Status | Links | |||
| John Jay | 8 | Yeshiva | 3 | Final | • | |
| Keuka | 5 | Grinnell | 8 | Final | • | BX |
| Castleton | 1 | Thomas | 2 | Final | • * | BX |
| SUNY Oneonta | 2 | Brockport | 10 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| John Jay | 12 | Yeshiva | 2 | Final | • | |
| Castleton | 12 | Thomas | 4 | Final | • * | BX |
| Rochester | 10 | RPI | 1 | Final | • * | BX |
| Penn State-Behrend | 2 | Roanoke | 8 | Final | • | BX |
| UW-Whitewater | 13 | St. Thomas | 1 | Final | • | BX RC |
| Castleton | 9 | Thomas | 2 | Final | • * | BX |
| Rochester | 6 | RPI | 10 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Middlebury | 8 | Carthage | 13 | Final | • | BX RC |