The D3baseball.com Preseason All-America team is chosen from previous years' All-American and All-Region nominations.
First Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Alex Kachler | Methodist | Sr. | Lithia, Fla. |
| 1B | Tim Johnson | Sul Ross State | Sr. | Sante Fe, Texas |
| 2B | Harry Witwer-Dukes | Wooster | Sr. | Monmouth, Ore |
| 3B | Daniel Montgomery Jr. | Southwestern | Sr. | Boling, Texas |
| SS | Max Lahn | Denison | Jr. | Charlotte, N.C. |
| OF | Connor Harding | Scranton | Jr. | Vestal. N.Y. |
| OF | Alex Mumme | Ursinus | Sr. | Montgomery, N.J. |
| OF | Bret Williams | Penn State Harrisburg | Sr. | Mount Carmel, Pa. |
| DH | Dan Harwood | Wooster | Sr. | Brecksville, Ohio |
| UTIL | David Larson | WPI | Sr. | Port Tobacco, Md. |
| SP | Jonathan Cole | Franklin & Marshall | Sr. | Cherry Hill, N.J. |
| SP | Nolan McCarthy | Occidental | Sr. | Portland, Ore. |
| SP | Zach Pronschinske | UW-La Crosse | Sr. | Arcadia, Wisc. |
| SP | Luke Summers | Fontbonne | Sr. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| RP | Nick Garcia | Chapman | Jr. | San Carlos, Calif. |
Second Team
| C | Rob Marinec | North Central (Ill.) | Jr. | Alsip, Ill. |
| 1B | Davis Mikell | Castleton | Sr. | Williston, Vt. |
| 2B | Bryce Rheault | Buena Vista | Sr. | North Las Vegas |
| 3B | Clayton Noakes | Louisiana College | Jr. | Dry Prong, La. |
| SS | Eric Meyer | Spalding | Sr. | Frankfort, Kent. |
| OF | Colin BeVard | Cortland | Sr. | Syracuse, N.Y. |
| OF | AJ Gill | Aurora | Sr. | Jacksonville, Fla. |
| OF | Antony Mantova | St. John Fisher | Sr. | Albany, N.Y. |
| DH | Jeremy Jess | Pomona-Pitzer | Sr. | San Luis Obispo, Calif. |
| UTIL | John Brinkman | Washington (Mo.) | Sr. | Worden, Ill. |
| SP | James Green | Saint Mary’s (Minn.) | Jr. | East Bethel, Minn. |
| SP | Charlie Klemm | North Central (Ill.) | Jr. | Darien, Ill. |
| SP | Ben Lambert | Southern Maine | Sr. | Saco, Maine |
| SP | Mike Webb | Rhode Island College | Sr | Pawtucket, R.I. |
| RP | Gage Smart | Buena Vista | Sr. | Indianola, Iowa |
Honorable Mention
| C | Gunner Rainey | Adrian | Sr. | Adrian, Mich. |
| 1B | Allen Murphy | St. John Fisher | Sr. | Richburg, N.Y. |
| 2B | Eric Pappas | Williams | Jr. | Providence, R.I. |
| 3B | Brian McAuliffe | Denison | Sr. | Tuckahoe, N.Y. |
| SS | Justin Graham | St. John Fisher | Jr. | Webster, N.Y. |
| OF | Scott Giordano | Cortland | Sr. | Croton-on-Hudson, N.Y. |
| OF | Trey Hicks | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Poquoson, Va. |
| OF | Noah Jensen | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Kenosha, Wisc. |
| DH | Joey Stock | St. John's (Minn) | Sr. | Cold Spring, Minn. |
| UTIL | Frank LoGiudice | Kean | Sr. | Edison, N.J. |
| SP | Jack Hodgins | Hendrix | So. | Simi Valley, Calif. |
| SP | Zack Jones | Rockford | Sr. | Rockford, Ill. |
| SP | Garrett Renslow | Rochester | Sr. | Castleton, N.Y. |
| SP | Matthew Williams | Concordia Texas | Sr. | Austin, Texas |
| RP | Brendan Shamieh | Rochester | Sr. | Whippany, N.J. |