D3baseball.com has picked All-America teams since its inception in 2007. Here's the easy way to get to all of them.
| Year | Player of the Year | Pitcher of the Year | Rookie of the Year |
| 2023 | Jack Thomson, 3B, Lewis & Clark | Brett Sanchez, Belhaven | Ryar Rinehart, Kalamazoo |
| 2022 | Ryan McCarty, SS, Penn State-Abington | Jimmy Adkins, Salisbury | Tyler Quade, Mount Aloysius |
| 2021 | Adam Zebrowski, C, St. John Fisher | Matt Mulhearn, Webster | Drew Bryan, Chicago |
| 2020 | No team selected | ||
| 2019 | Toby Welk, SS, Penn State Berks | John Howard, Washington U. | Jack Hodges, Hendrix |
| 2018 | Daytona Bryden, OF, UW-Whitewater | Connor Reeves, Salisbury | Ryan McCarty, Penn State Abington |
| 2017 | Pete Grasso, P/2B, Salisbury | Josh Fleming, Webster | Anthony Brophy, St. John Fisher |
| 2016 | Taylor Kohlwey, OF, UW-La Crosse | Seth Lamando, Cortland | Nathan Malinovsk, Texas Lutheran |
| 2015 | Sam Dexter, SS, Southern Maine | Blake Stevens, Birmingham-Southern | Austin Filiere, MIT |
| 2014 | Tad Gold, OF, Endicott | Chris Haddeland, Linfield | Ryan Dorow, Adrian |
| 2013 | Tucker White, OF, Southern Maine | Chris Haddeland, Linfield | Hayden Tsutsui, Carleton |
| 2012 | Bruce Maxwell, C, Birmingham-Southern | Austin Blaski, Marietta | Apolinar De la Cruz, Wheaton (Mass.) |
| 2011 | Chad Mullins, 3B, Case Western Reserve | Brian Gasser, Marietta | |
| 2010 | Dave Kahn, OF, Johns Hopkins | Matt Schuld, St. Thomas | |
| 2009 | Drew Hedman, 1B, Pomona-Pitzer | Jeremiah Bayer, Trinity (Conn.) | |
| 2008 | Derek David, 3B, McMurry | Kenny Moreland, Christopher Newport | |
| 2007 | Zach Lutz, 3B, Alvernia | Jim Dougher, Cortland | |
Preseason All-America teams