Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Patrick Keohane, OF, Sr., John Carroll
Pitcher of the Year: Danny Cody, Sr., Baldwin Wallace
Rookie of the Year: Maxwell Denny, SP, Adrian
Coach of the Year: Chad Fitzgerald, Heidelberg
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Gunner Rainey | Adrain | Jr. | Adrian, Mich. |
| 1B | Will Krushena | Denison | Jr. | Bloomfield Hills, Mich. |
| 2B | Joe Professori | La Roche | Sr. | Wexford, Pa. |
| SS | Max Lahn | Denison | So. | Charlotte, N.C. |
| 3B | Brian McAuliffe | Denison | Jr. | Tuckahoe, N.Y. |
| OF | Nick Fowkes | Thiel | Sr. | New Eagle, Pa. |
| OF | Patrick Keohane | John Carroll | Sr. | Quincy, Mass. |
| OF | Matt Psychas | Heidelberg | Sr. | Ypsilanti, Mich. |
| DH | Dan Harwood | Wooster | Jr. | Brecksville, Ohio |
| UTL | Dugan Darnell | Adrian | Sr. | Northville, Mich. |
| SP | Danny Cody | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Medina, Ohio |
| SP | Maxwell Denny | Adrian | Fr. | South Lyon, Mich |
| SP | Phil Mary | Mount Union | Sr. | Venetia, Pa. |
| RP | Scott Kutschke | Case Western Reserve | Jr. | Morton Grove, Ill. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Brendan Mapes | Oberlin | Sr. | Mount Vernon, Ohio |
| 1B | Bobby Finn | Saint Vincent | Sr. | Venetia, Pa. |
| 2B | Harry Witwer-Dukes | Wooster | Jr. | Monmouth, Ore |
| SS | Sam Claycamp | Franklin | Sr. | Columbus, Ind. |
| 3B | Kyle Jenkins | Heidelberg | Jr. | Wheelersburg, Ohio |
| OF | Patrick O'Leary | Kenyon | Jr. | Killingworth, Conn. |
| OF | Jake Ryan | Case Western Reserve | So. | Chatma, Ill. |
| OF | Jonathan Spina | La Roche | Sr. | Washington, Pa. |
| DH | Grady Paine | Denison | Sr. | McLean, Va. |
| UTL | Chandler Dippman | Wooster | Sr. | Waterville, Ohio |
| SP | Luke Buehler | Rose-Hulman | Jr. | Carmel, Ind. |
| SP | Nick Denove | Case Western Reserve | Fr. | Naples, Fla. |
| SP | Mason Miller | Waynesburg | Jr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| RP | Collin Hoffmann | Otterbein | Jr. | Galena, Ohio |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Marc Ochoa | Heidelberg | Jr. | North Royalton, Ohio |
| 1B | Garrett Crum | Wooster | Sr. | Alliance, Ohio |
| 2B | Mullen Socha | Wash. & Jeff. | Sr. | Independence, Ohio |
| SS | Jacob Stuursma | Wooster | Sr. | Hudson, Ohio |
| 3B | Jacob Kucia | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Strongsville, Ohio |
| OF | Ryan Bixler | Franklin | Jr. | Logansport, Ind. |
| OF | Mason Opple | Hope | Jr. | Hudsonville, Mich. |
| OF | Ty Robinson | Denison | So. | Hoover, Ala. |
| DH | Danny Doran | Alfred St. | Sr. | Irondequoit, N.Y. |
| UTL | Joe Moran | Anderson | Jr. | Anderson, Ind. |
| SP | Mo Hanley | Adrian | So. | Tampa, Fla |
| SP | Ben Marsico | Wash. & Jeff. | Jr. | Bradford Woods, Pa. |
| SP | Tre Thomas | La Roche | Jr. | Ambridge, Pa. |
| RP | Mitchell Taufer | Wash. & Jeff. | Sr. | Washington, Pa. |