Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Wes Meadows, Utl., Sr.,
Otterbein
Pitcher of the Year: Eddie Nogay, Jr., Washington
and Jefferson
Rookie of the Year: Jason Byers, SP, Marietta
Coach of the Year: Rick Espeset, Manchester
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Alex Toth | Marietta |
Sr. |
Painesville, Ohio |
| 1B | Jimmy Spagna |
John Carroll |
Jr. | Libertyville, Ill. |
| 2B | Eddie Reese |
Wooster | Jr. | Canfield, Ohio |
| SS | Corey Marchant |
Manchester | Sr. |
Fort Wayne, Ind. |
| 3B | Jordan Nieman |
Manchester | Jr. |
Michigan City, Ind. |
| OF | Josh Staniscia | Washington and Jefferson | Jr. | Export, Pa. |
| OF | Brendan Toughey |
Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | East Amherst, N.Y. |
| OF | Jarrod Mancine |
Wooster | Jr. | Sarver, Pa. |
| DH | Jarod Nanna |
Thiel | Sr. | Johnstown, Pa. |
| U | Wes Meadows |
Otterbein | Sr. |
Marion, Ohio |
| SP | Keenan White |
Wooster | Sr. |
Dublin, Ohio |
| SP | Jarrett Gish |
Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Jupiter, Fla. |
| SP | Eddie Nogay |
Washington and Jefferson | Jr. |
Weirton, W.Va. |
| RP | David Etscheid |
Thomas More | Sr. |
Union, Ky. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Bryan Miller |
Wooster | Jr. | Brecksville, Ohio |
| 1B | Evan Knott |
Mount Union | Jr. | Canton, Ohio |
| 2B | Trevor Kimm |
Manchester | Sr. | Anderson, Ind. |
| SS | Matt Keen |
Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Tallmadge, Ohio |
| 3B | Anthony Morino |
Mount Union | So. |
Strongsville, Ohio |
| OF | Grant Van Putten |
Calvin | So. | Holland, Mich. |
| OF | Brandon Reaman |
Wittenberg | So. |
Dayton, Ohio |
| OF | Jordan Grilliot |
Marietta | Sr. | Brookville, Ohio |
| DH | Dan Heatherly |
Adrian | Jr. | Trenton, Mich. |
| U | Bryce Murphy |
Manchester | So. |
Ossian, Ind. |
| SP | Zach Carlino |
Mount Union | Jr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| SP | James Connelly |
La Roche | Sr. | West Deer, Pa. |
| SP | Jason Byers |
Marietta | Fr. | East Granby, Conn. |
| RP | Eric Strickler | Alma | So. | Lapeer, Mich. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jesse Wilson | Franklin | Sr. | Seymour, Ind. |
| 1B | Vinny Rice |
Penn St.-Behrend | Sr. | Harmony, Pa. |
| 2B | Paul Pakan |
Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Tallmadge, Ohio |
| SS | Kyle Clemmenson |
Denison | Sr. | Katonah, N.Y. |
| 3B | Anthony Sergi | Adrian | Sr. | Northville, Mich. |
| OF | Eric Steininger |
Theil |
Sr. | West Leechburg, Pa. |
| OF | Kyle Niermann |
Bluffton | So. | Napoleon, Ohio |
| OF | Sam Fischer |
Adrian | Jr. |
Monclova, Ohio |
| DH | Tyler Hutchinson |
Wittenberg | Jr. | Lebanon, Ohio |
| U | Nick Rossmiller |
Thiel | Sr. |
Butler, Pa. |
| SP | Kyle Konarski |
Manchester | Sr. | Elkhart, Ind. |
| SP | Derrick Capiak |
Mt. Aloysius | So. | Williamstown, N.J. |
| SP | Justin Scott |
Manchester | Sr. | Fort Wayne, Ind. |
| RP | Jesse Bauer |
La Roche | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |