Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Brady Ballstadt, OF, Jr., Piedmont
Pitcher of the Year: Connor Reeves, SP, Sr., Salisbury
Rookie of the Year: Spence Johns, 2B, Berry
Coach of the Year: Ray Hedrick, Randolph-Macon
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jacob Delk | Berry | Sr. | Alpharetta, Ga. |
| 1B | Andrew Mink | Oglethorpe | Jr. | Clearwater, Fla. |
| 2B | Spence Johns | Berry | Fr. | Dacula, Ga. |
| SS | Chris Seibert | Wesley | Sr. | Pitman, N.J. |
| 3B | Seth Woodard | Christopher Newport | Jr. | Newport News, Va. |
| OF | Brady Ballstadt | Piedmont | Jr. | Suwanee, Ga. |
| OF | Sean Guida | Roanoke | Sr. | Summit, N.J. |
| OF | Justin Meekins | Salisbury | So. | Berlin, Md. |
| DH | Keegan Woolford | Shenandoah | So. | Charlottesville, Va. |
| UTL | Jacob Pilarski | Virginia Wesleyan | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| SP | Austin Heenan | Salisbury | Sr. | Melfa, Va. |
| SP | Connor Reeves | Salisbury | Sr. | Bel Air, Md. |
| SP | Colin Selby | Randolph-Macon | Jr. | Chesapeake, Va. |
| RP | Joe Burris | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Charlottesville, Va. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Alex Kachler | Methodist | So. | Lithia, Fla. |
| 1B | Joseph Tuzzolo | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Newport News, Va. |
| 2B | Cameron Upton | Gallaudet | Jr. | Vicksburg, Miss. |
| SS | Matthias Carter | Methodist | So. | Pembroke, N.C. |
| 3B | Jack Barry | Salisbury | Jr. | Laurel, Md. |
| OF | Jordan Eckard | Pfeiffer | Sr. | Catfish, N.C. |
| OF | Cole Migliorini | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Stafford, Va. |
| OF | Grant Oberholtzer | York (Pa.) | Jr. | Lancaster, Pa. |
| DH | Brandon Ginch | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Fairfax, Va. |
| UTL | Nick Bosma | Rhodes | Jr. | Overland Park, Kan. |
| SP | Sam Carpenter | Piedmont | So. | Gainesville, Ga. |
| SP | Colin Morse | Shenandoah | Sr. | Vienna, Va. |
| SP | Thomas Packert | Christopher Newport | So. | Chesapeake, Va. |
| RP | Buddy Green | Piedmont | Sr. | Sharpsburg, Ga. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Reece Yeargain | Randolph-Macon | So. | Richmond, Va. |
| 1B | Andrew Burden | Piedmont | Jr. | Sharpsburg, Ga. |
| 2B | Will Toner | Birmingham Southern | So. | Atlanta, Ga. |
| SS | Brandon Kussmaul | Virginia Wesleyan | Sr. | Virginia Beach, Va. |
| 3B | Devin Post | Berry | Jr. | Lakeland, Fla. |
| OF | Seth Brosius | York (Pa.) | Sr. | Magnolia, Del. |
| OF | Ryan Duphorn | Randolph-Macon | So. | Erial, N.J. |
| OF | Grant Thompson | Shenandoah | So. | Springfield, Va. |
| DH | Adrian Celata | Oglethorpe | Sr. | Duluth, Ga. |
| UTL | Richard Brereton | Emory | So. | Darien, Conn. |
| SP | Jake Cook | Birmingham Southern | Jr. | Oxford, Ala. |
| SP | Trey Rampy | Berry | Sr. | Locust Grove, Ga. |
| SP | Greg Schneider | Frostburg State | Sr. | Jefferson Hills, Pa. |
| RP | Gibson Bittner | LaGrange | Fr. | Arcadia, Fla. |