Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Riley Schaefer, OF, Sr., Texas Lutheran
Pitcher of the Year: Nathan Malinovsky, SP, Jr., Texas Lutheran
Rookie of the Year: Kyle Strash, 2B, Puget Sound
Coach of the Year: Aaron Swick, Willamette
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jack Brett | Willamette | Sr. | Aurora, Colo. |
| 1B | Barry Casey | Texas-Dallas | Sr. | Southlake, Texas |
| 2B | Carson Cox | Concordia (Texas) | Jr. | Cotulla, Texas |
| SS | Aaron Singh | Redlands | Jr. | Anaheim, Calif. |
| 3B | Brendan Gardiner | Redlands | Sr. | Mission Viejo, Calif. |
| OF | Jacob Bockelie | Pacific Lutheran | Sr. | Shoreline, Wash. |
| OF | Tyler Cauley | Texas Lutheran | So. | Baytown, Texas |
| OF | Riley Schaefer | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Thorndale, Texas |
| DH | CJ Novogradac | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | Jr. | Oakland, Calif. |
| UT | Matt Voelzke | George Fox | So. | Lake Oswego, Ore. |
| SP | Dylan Drgac | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Caldwell, Texas |
| SP | Nathan Malinovsky | Texas Lutheran | Jr. | New Braunfels, Texas |
| SP | Adam Stead | Redlands | Sr. | Rialto, Calif. |
| RP | Justin Traxler | Concordia (Texas) | Sr. | Austin, Texas |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Rainier Aguilar | Redlands | Sr. | San Bernardino, Calif |
| 1B | Ryan Almager | Sul Ross State | Sr. | Lubbock, Texas |
| 2B | Ryan Burciaga | Texas-Dallas | Jr. | Katy, Texas, |
| SS | Bowie Farris | Texas-Tyler | Jr. | Denton, Texas |
| 3B | Connor Scruggs | Texas-Dallas | Sr. | Garland, Texas |
| OF | Jonathon Bigley | Sul Ross State | Sr. | Dripping Springs, Texas |
| OF | Rafe Chaumette | Trinity (Texas) | So. | Sugar Land, Texas |
| OF | Ryan Ross | Linfield | Sr. | Yakima, Wash. |
| DH | Thomas Craig | Texas-Dallas | Jr. | Austin, Texas |
| UT | Cole Johnson | Pacific Lutheran | Sr. | Buckley, Wash. |
| SP | Matthew Devillier | Centenary (La.) | Jr. | Lake Charles, La. |
| SP | Tyler Peck | Chapman | Jr. | Corte Madera, Calif. |
| SP | Hugh Smith | Whitworth | Jr. | Sammamish, Wash. |
| RP | Jeff Lonnecker | Trinity (Texas) | Jr. | Bellaire, Texas |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Elijah Perez | Hardin-Simmons | Sr. | San Marcos, Texas |
| 1B | Matthew Macey | Whittier | Sr. | Oceanside, Calif. |
| 2B | Will Hall | Redlands | Sr. | Seattle, Wash. |
| SS | Casen Novak | Concordia (Texas) | So. | Flatonia, Texas |
| 3B | Nathan Patton | University of Dallas | So. | McKinney, Texas |
| OF | Connor Bailey | Willamette | Jr. | San Diego, Calif. |
| OF | Tristan Kevitch | Chapman | Jr. | Ardmore, Pa. |
| OF | Wesley Moss | Sul Ross State | Jr. | San Antonio, Texas |
| DH | Keaton Boysen | Texas Lutheran | Sr. | Scottsdale, Ariz. |
| UT | Deauton Delgado | Louisiana College | Jr. | Shreveport, La. |
| SP | Felix Minjarez | Redlands | Sr. | Riverside, Calif. |
| SP | Matt Mogollon | Chapman | Jr. | Torrance, Calif. |
| SP | Simon Sedillo | Texas-Tyler | Sr. | Grand Praire, Texas |
| RP | Cole Lavergne | Centenary (La.) | Sr. | Sulphur, La. |