Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Adam Zebrowski, Jr. C, St. John Fisher
Pitcher of the Year: Joe Raab, Sr., Merchant Marine
Rookie of the Year: James Murphy, 3B, St. John Fisher
Coach of the Year: Michael Notebaert, Merchant Marine
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Adam Zebrowski | St. John Fisher | Jr. | Albany, N.Y. |
| 1B | Brian Norsen | St. John Fisher | So. | Hamburg, N.Y. |
| 2B | Noah Campanelli | St. John Fisher | So. | Rochester, N.Y. |
| SS | Justin Graham | St. John Fisher | Sr. | Orlando, Fla. |
| 3B | Kyle Lauria | Oswego State | Sr. | Point Pleasant, N.J. |
| OF | Luke Duffy | St. John Fisher | Jr. | Otisville, N.Y. |
| OF | Scott Giordano | Cortland | Sr. | Croton-on-Hudson, N.Y. |
| OF | Aaron Whitley | Rochester | So. | Niskayuna, N.Y. |
| DH | Paul Franzese | Cortland | Sr. | Somers, N.Y. |
| UTL | Tom Kretzler | SUNY Brockport | Sr. | Albany, N.Y. |
| SP | Anthony Brophy | St. John Fisher | Sr. | North Tonawanda, N.Y. |
| SP | Rj Kuruts | St. John Fisher | Sr. | Forest City, Pa. |
| SP | Joe Raab | Merchant Marine | Sr. | Edwardsburg, Mich. |
| RP | Bailey Gauthier | Cortland | Sr. | Camillus, N.Y. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | John Moses | Rochester | So. | Union City, Ga. |
| 1B | Matteo Avallone | Alfred State | Jr. | Mahopac, N.Y. |
| 2B | Ryan Enos | Oswego State | Sr. | Oriskany, N.Y. |
| SS | Colin Kelly | Union | Sr. | Old Greenwich, Conn. |
| 3B | James Murphy | St. John Fisher | Fr. | Niskayuna, N.Y. |
| OF | Colin BeVard | Cortland | Sr. | Syracuse, N.Y. |
| OF | Jake Blinstrub | Mt. St. Vincent | Jr. | Peachtree, Ga. |
| OF | Ryan Mansell | SUNY Brockport | Jr. | Lancaster, N.Y. |
| DH | Colby Brouillette | Clarkson | So. | Georgia, Vt. |
| UTL | Buzz Shirley | Ithaca | Sr. | Candor, N.Y. |
| SP | Kieran Finnegan | Oswego State | Jr. | West Nyack, N.Y. |
| SP | Ryan Flansburg | Cortland | Sr. | Queensbury, N.Y. |
| SP | Tim Woodford | Old Westbury | Gr. | Smithtown, N.Y. |
| RP | Andrew Hunt | Merchant Marine | Sr. | Severna Park, Md. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | James Varian | Cortland | Jr. | Hopewell Junction, N.Y. |
| 1B | Matthew Krafft | Cortland | So. | Cornwall, N.Y. |
| 2B | Joseph Rende | Rochester | Jr. | Babylon, N.Y. |
| SS | Paul Tammaro | Oswego State | Jr. | New City, N.Y. |
| 3B | Michael Grisanti | Mt. St. Vincent | Jr. | Massapequa, N.Y. |
| OF | Garrett Callaghan | Ithaca | Sr. | Franklin Park, N.J. |
| OF | Brendon Frank | Oswego State | Sr. | Saratoga Springs, N.Y. |
| OF | Jayson Maxwell | SUNY Cobleskill | Sr. | Newport, N.Y. |
| OF | James Ward | St. John Fisher | Fr. | Queensbyry, N.Y. |
| DH | Derek Shea | Wells | Sr. | West Kingston, R.I. |
| UTL | Stephen Tejada | SUNY Cobleskill | Fr. | Queens, N.Y. |
| SP | Stephen Clancy | Farmingdale State | Jr. | Mineola, N.Y. |
| SP | Kevin Czeczotka | St. Joseph's (L.I.) | Jr. | East Northport, N.Y. |
| SP | Zack Durant | Cortland | Sr. | Verona, N.Y. |
| SP | Ryan Yerby | RPI | Sr. | Montara, Calif. |
| RP | Alec Teska | St. John Fisher | Jr. | Cato, N.Y. |