Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Jake Studley, Sr., OF, Wheaton (Mass.)
Pitcher of the Year: Stephen Quigley, Sr., SP, Wheaton (Mass.)
Rookie of the Year: Jason Johnson, SP, St. Joseph's (Maine)
Coach of the Year: Mike Leonard, Middlebury
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | John Collins | Middlebury | So. | New York, N.Y. |
| 1B | Peter DeMaria | Tufts | Sr. | Chatham, N.J. |
| 2B | Drew Healey | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Gr. | Rochester, N.H. |
| SS | Eddy Garcia | SUNY Cobleskill | Sr. | Bronx, N.Y. |
| 3B | Ronan Chisholm | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Sr. | North Chatham, Mass. |
| OF | Samuel Gutierrez | SUNY Cobleskill | Sr. | Bayside, N.Y. |
| OF | Miles Reid | Tufts | Sr. | Silver Spring, Md. |
| OF | Jake Studley | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Barrington, R.I. |
| DH | Mitchell Schroeder | Middlebury | Jr. | Brookline, Mass. |
| UTL | Vaun Larisa | Lasell | Fr. | Lincoln, R.I. |
| SP | Jason Johnson | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Fr. | Thomaston, Conn. |
| SP | Stephen Quigley | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Halifax, Mass. |
| SP | Griffin Young | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Dover, N.H. |
| RP | George Goldstein | Middlebury | Sr. | Westport, Conn. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Zach DeMattio | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | North Attleboro, Mass. |
| 1B | Noah Bleakley | Springfield | Gr. | Granby, Mass. |
| 2B | Brady Slinger | Hamilton | Sr. | Nashville, Tenn. |
| SS | Jacob Hand | WPI | So. | Niskayuna, N.Y. |
| 3B | Brady O'Brien | Colby | So. | North Andover, Mass. |
| OF | Blake Carroll | Coast Guard | Jr. | Land O'Lakes, Fla. |
| OF | Teddy Schoenfeld | MIT | So. | Boulder, Col. |
| OF | Jason Shell | Anna Maria | Gr. | Sandwich, Mass. |
| DH | Matthew Bischof | Lasell | Sr. | Sleepy Hollow, N.Y. |
| UTL | Alec Ritch | Middlebury | Jr. | Kentfield, Calif. |
| SP | Nick Choate | Anna Maria | Fr. | Grafton, Mass. |
| SP | Tim Noone | Babson | Jr. | Needham, Mass. |
| SP | Alex Price | Middlebury | Jr. | Ridgefield, Conn. |
| SP | Gavin Reily | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Bridgewater, Mass. |
| RP | Stephen McLendon | Babson | Jr. | Nashua, N.H. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Tyler Parke | Husson | Sr. | Bangor, Maine |
| 1B | Jeremy Rosenberg | Anna Maria | Fr. | Boynton Beach, Fla. |
| 2B | Kyle Sonandres | MIT | Jr. | Torrance, Calif. |
| 2B | Thomas Lapham | Babson | Sr. | Charlestown, Mass. |
| SS | Kosta Drosidis | Anna Maria | Sr. | Holden, Mass. |
| 3B | Jack Simonetty | Springfield | Gr. | Wappingers Falls, N.Y. |
| OF | Phil Bernstein | Hamilton | Jr. | Brooklyn, N.Y. |
| OF | Hunter Dunithan | Anna Maria | Jr. | Reno, Nev. |
| OF | Jimmy Evans | Tufts | Jr. | Norwalk, Conn. |
| DH | Elijah Spataj | Anna Maria | Jr. | Cheshire, Conn. |
| SP | Graham Cartwright | MIT | Jr. | La Jolla, Calif. |
| SP | Matt Poff | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Sr. | Pelham, N.H. |
| SP | Tristen Spalter | Babson | So. | Sergeantsville, N.J. |
| RP | Dom Cunha | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Lincoln, R.I. |