The D3baseball.com preseason preseason All-America team is chosen from previous years' All-American and All-Region nominations.
First Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Chris Zapata | Centenary (La.) | Sr. | Saratoga, Calif. |
| 1B | Chris Fowler | UMass Boston | Sr. | Barnstable, Mass. |
| 2B | Mitch Wilson | Concordia Chicago | Sr. | Oswego, Ill. |
| 3B | Michael Mateja | North Central (Ill.) | Jr. | Bourbonnais, Ill. |
| SS | Bryan VanDuser | Concordia Chicago | Jr. | Plainfield, Ill. |
| OF | Billy Goodall | Mount Union | Sr. | Canfield, Ohio |
| OF | Dylan Hapworth | Southern Maine | So. | Winslow, Maine |
| OF | Cole Migliorini | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Stafford, Va. |
| DH | Ryan Arena | Babson | Sr. | Yorktown Heights, N.Y. |
| UTIL | Ryan Orr | Kalamazoo | Sr. | DeWitt, Mich. |
| SP | Billy Dimlow | Emory | Jr. | Sammamish, Wash. |
| SP | Phil Mary | Mount Union | Jr. | Venetia, Pa. |
| SP | Heath Renz | UW-Whitewater | Jr. | Jefferson, Wis. |
| RP | Matt Curry | TCNJ | Sr. | Marlton, N.J. |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Rainier Aguilar | Redlands | Sr. | San Bernardino, Calif. |
| 1B | Walker Breard | Cornell | Sr. | Washington, Iowa |
| 2B | Kyle Hartenstein | Mitchell | Sr. | Meriden, Conn. |
| 3B | Toby Welk | Penn State Berks | Jr. | Downingtown, Pa. |
| SS | Kyle Bonicki | Clark | Sr. | Waterbury, Conn. |
| OF | Brady Chant | Suffolk | Sr. | Warwick, R.I. |
| OF | Evan Delaney | New England College | Jr. | Hadley, Mass. |
| OF | Wyatt Ulrich | Saint John’s (Minn.) | So. | Indus, Minn. |
| DH | Cody Crowder | Centenary (La.) | So. | Shepherd, Texas |
| UTIL | Joseph Salmen | Westminster (Pa.) | Sr. | New Castle, Pa. |
| SP | Joe Cirillo | TCNJ | Sr. | Fairfield, N.J. |
| SP | Jimi Keating | Spalding | Sr. | Bardstown, Ky. |
| SP | Felix Minjarez | Redlands | Sr. | Riverside, Calif. |
| RP | Nathan Schneidermann | Dubuque | Jr. | German Valley, Ill. |
Honorable mention
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Timmy Gorton | Eastern | Sr. | Miller Place, N.Y. |
| 1B | Chris Rebar | King’s | Sr. | Scranton, Pa. |
| 2B | Max Weinstein | Cal Lutheran | Sr. | Canyon Country, Calif. |
| 3B | Jack Barry | Salisbury | Jr. | Laurel, Md. |
| SS | Michael Wielansky | Wooster | Jr. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| OF | Josh Covey | Texas Dallas | Sr. | Tomball, Texas |
| OF | Steven Neutzling | St. Scholastica | Sr. | St. Cloud, Minn. |
| OF | Chuck Probst | Gettysburg | Sr. | North Bend, Pa. |
| DH | AJ Johnson | Carroll | Sr. | Waunakee, Wis. |
| UTIL | Christopher Peres | La Verne | Jr. | Burbank, Calif. |
| SP | Cason Cunningham | Linfield | Jr | Eugene, Ore. |
| SP | Austin Jones | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Wauwatosa, Wis. |
| SP | Tommy Parsons | Adrian | Sr. | New Albany, Ohio |
| RP | T.J. Storer | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Loveland, Ohio |