Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: OF Eric Colaco, Sr., Denison
Pitcher of the Year: SP Michael Vallone, Sr., DePauw
Rookie of the Year: C Jack Lutte, Denison
Coach of the Year: Mike Deegan, Denison
First Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jack Anderson | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Clarkston, Mich. |
| 1B | Dane Camphausen | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | McLean, Va. |
| 2B | Alex Richter | Marietta | Jr. | Carmel, Ind. |
| SS | Brayden Quincel | Otterbein | Sr. | Grove City, Ohio |
| 3B | Patrick Gillen | Calvin | So. | Jensen Beach, Fla. |
| OF | Eric Colaco | Denison | Jr. | Richfield, Ohio |
| OF | James Domer | Pitt-Greensburg | So. | Connellsville, Pa. |
| OF | Scout Zaas | Washington & Jefferson | Jr. | Powell, Ohio |
| DH | Ryan Kramer | Wooster | So. | Chicago, Ill. |
| UTL | Tyler Quade | Mount Aloysius | Jr. | Mechanicsville, Md. |
| SP | Nick Guidas | Grove City | Sr. | Gibsonia, Pa. |
| SP | Will Rettig | Denison | So. | Perrysburg, Ohio |
| SP | Michael Vallone | DePauw | Sr. | Lake Forest, Ill. |
| RP | Gabe Torres | Marietta | Sr. | El Paso, Texas |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jack Lutte | Denison | Fr. | Venetia, Pa. |
| 1B | Avery Carnicom | Alma | Sr. | Woodhaven, Mich. |
| 2B | John Riviere-Vejas | Hilbert | Sr. | Brooklyn, N.Y. |
| SS | Jacob LaDuca | Washington & Jefferson | Jr. | Clarence, N.Y. |
| 3B | AJ Reid | Wabash | Sr. | Highland, Ind. |
| OF | Tyson Bryant-Dawson | Allegheny | Jr. | Oakland, Calif. |
| OF | Edrick Padilla | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Salinas, P.R. |
| OF | Kris Stojanovski | Albion | Jr. | Northville, Mich. |
| DH | Drew Garth | Washington & Jefferson | Jr. | Glenshaw, Pa. |
| UTL | Sam Bevin | Grove City | Fr. | Louisville, Ky. |
| SP | Zachary Breeden | Mount Union | Jr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| SP | Jakob Charles | Adrian | So. | San Angelo, Texas |
| SP | Tyler Walker | Baldwin Wallace | So. | Fairlawn, Ohio |
| RP | Joe Horoszko | Wittenberg | Sr. | Seven Hills, Ohio |
Third Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Harrison Poeszat | Kalamazoo | Sr. | Commerce Township, Mich. |
| 1B | Noah Leib | Denison | Sr. | Evanston, Ill. |
| 2B | Luke Thomas | Wittenberg | Sr. | Tallmadge, Ohio |
| SS | Silvio Ionadi | Penn State-Behrend | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| 3B | Alex Nemunaitis | Wittenberg | So. | Ottawa Hills, Ohio |
| OF | Nick Harms | Case Western Reserve | Jr. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| OF | Josh Minnich | Grove City | Jr. | Mechanicsburg, Pa. |
| OF | Robbie Stuursma | Hope | Sr. | East Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| DH | Nick Jacobs | Thiel | Sr. | New Castle, Pa. |
| UTL | Trent Valentine | Marietta | Sr. | Byesville, Ohio |
| SP | Colin Bolla | Penn State-Behrend | Fr. | Fairview, Pa. |
| SP | Trent Johnson | Hope | Jr. | Midland, Mich. |
| SP | Jackson Powers | Heidelberg | Jr. | Strongsville, Ohio |
| RP | Jake Manendo | Penn State-Behrend | Fr. | Erie, Pa. |