The D3baseball.com Preseason All-America team is chosen from previous years' All-American and All-Region nominations.
First Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Clay Sowell | Tufts | Jr. | Kingwood, Texas |
| 1B | Jack Barry | York (Pa.) | Gr. | New Fairfield, Conn. |
| 2B | Colby Martin | Shenandoah | So. | Lititz, Pa. |
| 3B | Luke Broadhurst | Eastern Connecticut St. | Sr. | Stafford, Conn. |
| SS | Austin Denlinger | York (Pa.) | Sr. | Elizabethtown, Pa. |
| OF | Turner Hill | Marietta | Sr. | Marietta, Ohio |
| OF | Jonathan Kelso | UW-Platteville | Sr. | Villa Park, Ill. |
| OF | Aaron Whitley | Rochester | Jr. | Niskayuna, N.Y. |
| DH | Max Nyrop | Saint John’s (Minn.) | Jr. | Alameda, Calif. |
| UTL | Tyler Horvat | Washington & Jefferson | Jr. | Irwin, Pa. |
| SP | Luke Lamm | North Central (Ill.) | Sr. | Bolingbrook, Ill. |
| SP | Henry Litman | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Marietta, Ga. |
| SP | Westin Muir | UW-Whitewater | Sr. | Highlands Ranch, Colo. |
| SP | Kyle Roche | Franklin & Marshall | Sr. | Sandy Hook, Conn. |
| RP | Drew Bryan | Chicago | So. | Sanford, N.C. |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Rob Marinec | North Central (Ill.) | Gr. | Alsip, Ill. |
| 1B | Peter Cosentino | Montclair St. | Sr. | Whitehouse Station, N.J. |
| 2B | Matt O’Leary | Beloit | Jr. | Clarendon Hills, Ill. |
| 3B | Jordan Haworth | Pacific Lutheran | Sr. | Gig Harbor, Wash. |
| SS | Alex Ludwick | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Brunswick, Ohio |
| OF | Dougie DelaCruz | Mitchell | Sr. | Uncasville, Conn. |
| OF | Scott Giordano | Cortland | Sr. | Croton-On-Hudson, N.Y. |
| OF | Bryce Novak | Gustavus Adolphus | Jr. | Cleveland, Minn. |
| DH | Vince Montone | Keystone | Sr. | Oak Ridge, N.J. |
| UTL | T.J. Johnson | Coe | Sr. | Cedar Rapids, Iowa |
| SP | Eli Atiya | Rowan | Jr. | Cherry Hill, N.J. |
| SP | Will Clark | Pacific | Jr. | Boise, Idaho |
| SP | T.J. Deardorff | Coe | Sr. | Dubuque, Iowa |
| SP | Peyton Hood | Spalding | Sr. | Louisville, Ky. |
| RP | Sam Mathews | Marietta | Sr. | Fairfield, Ohio |
Third Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Ryan Goodall | College of New Jersey | So. | Toms River, N.J. |
| 1B | Drew Holderbach | Marietta | Sr. | Fairfield, Ohio |
| 2B | Tim Van Kirk | Washington (Mo.) | Sr. | Arcadia, Calif. |
| 3B | Sam Beers | Concordia Wisconsin | Sr. | Janesville, Wis. |
| SS | Tyler Chumita | Wooster | Sr. | Hilliard, Ohio |
| OF | Dallas Hite | Penn St. Harrisburg | Sr. | Lilly, Pa. |
| OF | Ryan Murphy | Rowan | Sr. | Reading, Pa. |
| OF | Corey Vondra | Aurora | Sr. | Downers Grove, Ill. |
| DH | Kevin Bushnell | Benedictine | Sr. | Tinley Park, Ill. |
| UTL | Carter Ballstadt | Piedmont | Sr. | Gainesville, Ga. |
| SP | Daniel Johnson | Scranton | Jr. | Whitehouse Station, N.J. |
| SP | Gavin Reily | Wheaton (Mass.) | Sr. | Bridgewater, Mass. |
| SP | Brett Sanchez | Belhaven | So. | Slidell, La. |
| SP | Thomas Zbezinski | Penn St. Behrend | Sr. | Gibsonia, Pa. |
| RP | Sidney Ferry | UW-Stevens Point | Jr. | Paw Paw, Mich. |