Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Tim Saunders, SS, Sr.,
Marietta
Pitcher of the Year: Austin Blaski, Sr.,
Marietta
Rookie of the Year: Matt Brooks, DH, Hanover
Coach of the Year: Jake Martin, DePauw
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Alex Toth | Marietta |
Jr. |
Painesville, Ohio |
| 1B | Tim Wiand |
Westminster (Pa.) |
Sr. | Pottstown, Pa. |
| 2B | Garrett Green |
Adrian |
Jr. | Novi, Mich. |
| SS | Tim Saunders |
Marietta |
Sr. |
Alliance, Ohio |
| 3B | Mitchell Herringshaw |
John Carroll |
So. |
Cleveland, Ohio |
| OF | Josh Staniscia | Washington and Jefferson |
So. | Export, Pa. |
| OF | Kyle Strawn | Adrian | Sr. | Lima, Ohio |
| OF | Aaron Hopper | Marietta |
Jr. | Wheelersburg, Ohio |
| DH | Jesse Weiss |
Kenyon |
Jr. | Los Angeles, Calif. |
| U | Bryce Murphy |
Manchester |
Jr. |
Ossian, Ind. |
| SP | Austin Blaski | Marietta | Sr. |
Pandora, Ohio |
| SP | Jason Fryman | Adrian | Sr. | Dowagiac, Mich. |
| SP | Adam Clements | Hope |
Sr. |
Saline, Mich. |
| RP | Kyle Lindquist |
Marietta |
Sr. |
Columbus, Ohio |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Wes Meadows | Otterbein | Jr. | Marion, Ohio |
| 1B | Evan Brockmeier | Marietta | Jr. | Marietta, Ohio |
| 2B | Kirby Becker | Marietta | Sr. | South Euclid, Ohio |
| SS | Zach Starr | DePauw | So. | Fishers, Ind. |
| 3B | Jordan Nieman | Manchester |
So. |
Michigan City, Ind. |
| OF | Connor Mathis | Mount Union | So. | Akron, Ohio |
| OF | Ricardo Lizcano | Heidelberg | Sr. |
Toledo, Ohio |
| OF | Sam Fischer | Adrian | So. | Monclova, Ohio |
| DH | Matt Brooks | Hanover | Fr. | Goodlettsville, Tenn. |
| U | Zach Carlino | Mount Union |
So. |
Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| SP | Brian Gasser | Marietta |
Sr. | New Philadelphia, Ohio |
| SP | David Trushel | Washington and Jefferson |
Sr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| SP | Josh Stidham | Wooster |
Sr. |
Monclova, Ohio |
| RP | Jon Tenley | Baldwin-Wallace |
Jr. | Wadsworth, Ohio |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jesse Wilson | Franklin | Jr. | Seymour, Ind. |
| 1B | Andrew Thole | Thomas More | Sr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| 2B | Pat Lyons | DePauw | So. | Wildwood, Mo. |
| SS | Corey Marchant | Manchester | Jr. | Fort Wayne, Ind. |
| 3B | Alex Wright |
DePauw |
Sr. | Fishers, Ind. |
| OF | Brendan Toughey | Baldwin-Wallace |
Jr. | East Amherst, N.Y. |
| OF | Jonathan Ray | Wooster | Jr. | Columbus, Ohio |
| OF | Zach Galasso | St. Vincent |
Sr. |
Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| OF | Hank Akard | Rose-Hulman | Jr. | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| U | Brad Kubis | Bethany |
Jr. |
Aliquippa, Pa. |
| SP | Dustin Reuter | Otterbein | Sr. | Reynoldsburg, Ohio |
| SP | Nathan Ellis | Franklin | Sr. | Plainfield, Ind. |
| SP | Eric Schmidt | Adrian | Fr. | Blissfield, Mich. |
| RP | Daniel Brannum | Heidelberg | Sr. | Jamestown, Ohio |