Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Keith Shumaker, Utl., So.,
Millsaps
Pitcher of the Year: Austin Chrismon, Jr.,
Christopher Newport
Rookie of the Year: Mitchell Keeler, DH,
Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Jim Page, Millsaps
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Joseph Odom | Huntingdon | Jr. | Vestavia Hills, Ala. |
| 1B | Quinn Griffith |
Salisbury | Jr. |
Federalsburg, Md. |
| 2B | Kevin Wall |
Millsaps | Jr. | Birmingham, Ala. |
| SS | Jonathan Stutts |
Washington and Lee | Sr. |
Charlotte, N.C. |
| 3B | Stephen Gates |
Millsaps | Sr. |
Cocoa, Fla. |
| OF | Justin Weaver |
Christopher Newport | Jr. |
Nokesville, Va. |
| OF | Kevin Kean |
Frostburg St. | Jr. |
Millersville, Md. |
| OF | Nick Fulk |
Bridgewater (Va.) | Jr. |
Fulks Run, Va. |
| DH | Wes Perkins |
Millsaps | Sr. |
Geismar, LA |
| U | Keith Shumaker |
Millsaps | So. |
Brandon, Miss. |
| SP | Andrew Levy |
Salisbury | Sr. | Hampstead, Md. |
| SP | Martin Henderlite |
Lynchburg | So. |
Roanoke, Va. |
| SP | Austin Chrismon | Christopher Newport | Jr. |
Newport News, Va., |
| RP | Ryan Fleischmann |
Christopher Newport | Sr. |
Williamsburg, Va. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Dylan Shupe |
Frostburg St. | Jr. |
DelMar, Del. |
| 1B | Alex Maragos |
Washington and Lee | Sr. | Chicago, Ill. |
| 2B | Corey Wallace |
Guilford | Jr. | Rockingham, N.C. |
| SS | Tommy Barksdale |
Gallaudet | Sr. | Brookeville, Md. |
| 3B | Kent Peterson |
Guilford | Sr. |
Albemarle, N.C. |
| OF | John Macon Smith |
Guilford | Jr. |
Greensboro, N.C. |
| OF | Nick Gentry |
Salisbury | Sr. |
Bel Air, Md. |
| OF | Jeb Weymouth |
Randolph-Macon | Sr. |
Rockville, Va. |
| DH | Evan Graci |
Salisbury | Sr. | Harrisburg, Pa. |
| U | Andrew Kirks |
Averett |
Jr. | Dry Fork, Va. |
| SP | Miles Nordgren |
Birmingham Southern | Jr. |
Gadsden, Ala. |
| SP | Will Edwards |
Millsaps | Sr. | Kosciusko, Miss. |
| SP | Dan Fein |
Salisbury | So. | Southbury, Conn. |
| RP | Blake Yance |
Birmingham Southern | Sr. |
Chelsea, Ala. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jeff Brothers | Oglethorpe | Sr. |
East Sparta, Ohio |
| 1B | Jeff Gray |
Hampden-Sydney | So. | Newport News, Va. |
| 2B | J.K. Filauro |
Frostburg St. | Sr. |
South Salem, N.Y. |
| SS | Billy Steel |
Christopher Newport | Jr. | Mechanicsville, Va. |
| 3B | Andrew Hacker |
Bridgewater (Va.) | Sr. | Mechanicsville, Va. |
| OF | Jonathan Mason |
Bridgewater (Va.) | Sr. | Sterling, Va. |
| OF | Bill Root |
Salisbury | Jr. | Coatesville, Pa. |
| OF | Wes Peacock |
Emory | So. | Sherman Oaks, Calif. |
| DH | Mitchell Keeler |
Randolph-Macon | Fr. |
Mechanicsville, Va. |
| SP | Brandon Holsworth |
Gallaudet | So. |
Beal City, Mich. |
| SP | Bryan Bierlein |
Christopher Newport | Jr. |
Chesterfield, Va. |
| SP | Cory Belyeu |
Huntingdon | Sr. |
Prattville, Ala. |
| RP | Luke Rabiej |
Hampden-Sydney | Sr. | Alexandria, Va. |