Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Andrew Gronski, 3B, Jr.,
Case Western Reserve
Pitcher of the Year: Christian Herstine, So.,
Marietta
Rookie of the Year: Ryan Dorow, SS, Adrian
Coach of the Year: Matt Englander, Case Western
Reserve
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Chet Lauer |
John Carroll | Sr. |
University Heights, Ohio |
| 1B | Jimmy Spagna |
John Carroll | Sr. |
Libertyville, Ill. |
| 2B | Colin Feikles |
La Roche | Jr. |
Edinboro, Pa. |
| SS | Ryan Dorow |
Adrian | Fr. |
South Haven, Mich. |
| 3B | Andrew Gronski |
Case Western Reserve | Jr. |
Hilliard, Ohio |
| OF | Derek Hug |
Heidelberg | So. |
Bryan, Ohio |
| OF | Jarrod Mancine |
Wooster | Sr. |
Sarver, Pa. |
| OF | Josh Staniscia |
Washington and Jefferson | Sr. |
Export, Pa. |
| DH | Eric Monroe |
Heidelberg | Jr. |
Chagrin Falls, Ohio |
| U | Matt Schepel |
Calvin | Sr. |
Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| SP | Jason Byers |
Marietta | So. |
East Granby, Conn. |
| SP | Tyler Ferguson | La Roche | Jr. | Roaring Springs, Pa. |
| SP | Christian Herstine |
Marietta | So. |
Beaver, Pa. |
| RP | Andy Roenker |
Thomas More | Sr. |
Taylor Mill, Ky. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Chris Winpigler |
Marietta | Jr. |
Frederick, Md. |
| 1B | Kyle Chontos |
Baldwin Wallace | Jr. |
Pickerington, Ohio |
| 2B | Mark Zimmerman |
Baldwin Wallace | So. |
Akron, Ohio |
| SS | Andrew Frey |
Case Western Reserve | Sr. |
Mentor, Ohio |
| 3B | Mitch Stefanski |
Adrian | Sr. |
Oxford, Mich. |
| OF | Dan Belliveau |
Ohio Northern | Jr. |
Chardon, Ohio |
| OF | Jake Dunn |
Kenyon | Jr. |
Fairfield, Conn. |
| OF | Josh Ungerbuehler |
Marietta | Sr. |
Cincinnati, Ohio |
| DH | Nick Vento |
Washington and Jefferson | Fr. |
Murrysville, Pa. |
| U | Ryan Mulligan |
Denison | Jr. |
Raleigh, N.C. |
| SP | Holden Branch |
Adrian | Sr. |
Onsted, Mich. |
| SP | Nick Eltzroth |
Ohio Northern | So. |
Westerville, Ohio |
| SP | JT Miller |
Wabash | Sr. |
Wildwood, Mo. |
| RP | Derek Hendrixson |
Heidelberg | Fr. |
Centerville, Ohio |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jordan Swisher |
Case Western Reserve | Jr. |
Pittsford, N.Y. |
| 1B | Brian Tougher |
La Roche | Jr. |
Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| 2B | Kerrigan Cain |
Case Western Reserve | Jr. |
Hartville, Ohio |
| SS | Trevor Kimm |
Manchester | Jr. |
Anderson, Ind. |
| 3B | Frank Vance |
Wooster | Jr. |
Coraopolis, Pa. |
| OF | Sam Fischer |
Adrian | Sr. |
Monclova, Ohio |
| OF | Kyle Norris |
Manchester | Jr. |
Indianapolis, Ind. |
| OF | Trey Simpson |
Transylvania | So. |
Louisville, Ky. |
| DH | Hunter Handel |
Baldwin Wallace | So. |
Akron, Ohio |
| U | Benjamin Legath |
Mount Aloysius | Fr. |
Johnstown, Pa. |
| SP | John Fortunato |
Case Western Reserve | Sr. |
Toledo, Ohio |
| SP | Nolan Schaefer |
Anderson | Sr. |
Marshall, Ill. |
| SP | Cory Waite |
Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Willoughby, Ohio |
| RP | Kyle McLain |
Washington and Jefferson | Sr. |
East Amherst, N.Y. |