Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Michael Paul, 3B, Jr.,
Shenandoah
Pitcher of the Year: Blake Stevens, Jr.,
Birmingham-Southern
Rookie of the Year: Hans Hansen, SP, Emory
Coach of the Year: Doug
Fleetwood, Salisbury
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Casey Hicks | Gallaudet | Sr. |
Henderson, Nev. |
| 1B | John Macon Smith | Guilford | Sr. |
Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2B | Ricky Castro | Frostburg State | Jr. |
North Chesterfield, Va. |
| SS | Billy Steel | Christopher Newport | Sr. |
Mechanicsville, Va. |
| 3B | Michael Paul | Shenandoah | Jr. |
Red Hill, Pa. |
| OF | Keegan Dolan | Washington and Lee | Sr. |
Bethesda, Md. |
| OF | Kyle Hayman | Salisbury | Jr. |
Wilmington, Del. |
| OF | Brett Lake | Emory | Jr. |
Studio City, Calif. |
| DH | Nicholas Maiolo | Randolph-Macon | Jr. |
Powhatan, Va. |
| U | Keith Shumaker | Millsaps | Jr. |
Brandon, Miss. |
| SP | Brett Collacchi |
Salisbury | Jr. | Bear, Del. |
| SP | Miles Nordgren | Birmingham-Southern | Sr. |
Gadsden, Ala. |
| SP | Blake Stevens | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. |
Atlanta, Ga. |
| RP | David Bourbonnais | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. |
Atlanta, Ga. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Colbe Herr | York (Pa.) | Sr. |
Hummelstown, Pa. |
| 1B | Brad Wenzel | York (Pa.) | Sr. |
Blandon, Pa. |
| 2B | Will Cleland | Covenant | Jr. |
Jacksonville, Fla. |
| SS | Nick Dean | Maryville (Tenn.) | Sr. |
Mineral Bluff, Ga. |
| 3B | Corey Wallace | Guilford | Sr. |
Rockingham, N.C. |
| OF | William Bissell | Gallaudet | Sr. |
Brewer, Maine |
| OF | Brandon Hannon |
Emory | Sr. |
Peachtree City, Ga. |
| OF | Tommy Vitaletti | Christopher Newport | Jr. |
Williamsburg, Va. |
| DH | Derek Pitzer | York (Pa.) | Jr. |
York, Pa. |
| U | Adam Posey |
Eastern Mennonite | Sr. |
Poquoson, Va. |
| SP | Connor Dillman | Emory | Jr. |
Santa Monica, Calif. |
| SP | Jake Perkins | Ferrum | So. |
Appomattox, Va. |
| SP | Darrell Thompson | Shenandoah | So. |
Middletown, Va. |
| RP | Andrew Cooper | Wesley | Sr. |
Wilmington, Del. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jacob Mayfield | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. |
Gadsden, Ala. |
| 1B | Ricky Brady | Frostburg State | Jr. |
Waldorf, Md. |
| 2B | Johnny Schiotis | Salisbury | Sr. |
Levittown, Pa. |
| SS | Billy Arens | Shenandoah | So. |
Purcellville, Va. |
| 3B | Zach Weiss | Frostburg State | Jr. |
Pasadena, Md. |
| OF | Lincoln Evans | Lynchburg | Jr. |
Troutville, Va. |
| OF | Christian Hamlett | Hampden-Sydney | Jr. |
Midlothian, Va. |
| OF | Andrew Hershey |
York (Pa.) | Sr. |
Lancaster, Pa. |
| DH | Patrick Kulick | Oglethorpe | Jr. |
Coral Springs, Fla. |
| U | Taylor Davis | Averett | Jr. |
Clayton, N.C. |
| SP | Kenny Georgius | Frostburg State | Sr. |
Westminster, Md. |
| SP | Hans Hansen | Emory | Fr. |
Playa del Rey, Calif. |
| SP | Brandon Holsworth | Gallaudet | Jr. |
Beal City, Mich. |
| RP | Kyle Hamby | Salisbury | Jr. |
Laurel, Md. |