Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Ryan Hanahan, 3B, Sr., Marietta
Pitcher of the Year: Andrew Doring, Sr., John Carroll
Rookie of the Year: Kevin Zullo, SP, Ohio Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Chase Rowe, La Roche
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Chris Winpigler |
Marietta |
Sr. |
Frederick, Md. |
| 1B | Jaime Lackner |
Wooster |
So. |
Westlake, Ohio |
| 2B | Bobby Sabatino |
John Carroll |
Sr. | Waltham, Mass. |
| SS | Ryan Dorow |
Adrian |
So. |
South Haven, Mich. |
| 3B | Ryan Hanahan |
Marietta |
Sr. | Gibsonia, Pa. |
| OF | Jake Dunn |
Kenyon |
Sr. | Fairfield, Conn. |
| OF | Michael Fischbach |
Albion |
Jr. | Valencia, Calif. |
| OF | Derek Hug |
Heidelberg |
Jr. | Bryan, Ohio |
| DH | Donovan Pogue |
Thomas More |
Jr. | Sharonville, Ohio |
| U | Mark Zimmerman |
Baldwin Wallace |
Jr. | Akron, Ohio |
| SP | Andrew Doring |
John Carroll |
Sr. | Grafton, Wis. |
| SP | Tyler Ferguson |
La Roche |
Sr. | Roaring Springs, Pa. |
| SP | Eric Schmidt |
Adrian |
Sr. | Blissfield, Mich. |
| RP | Derek Hendrixson |
Heidelberg |
So. |
Centerville, Ohio |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Cole Heberling |
Anderson |
Sr. |
Anderson, Ind. |
| 1B | Tyler Gentile |
John Carroll |
Jr. |
Greenville, Pa. |
| 2B | Cole Nieto |
Baldwin Wallace |
So. |
Brunswick, Ohio |
| SS | John McLain |
Wooster |
Sr. | Burbank, Ohio |
| 3B | Frank Vance |
Wooster |
Sr. | Coraopolis, Pa. |
| OF | Dan Belliveau |
Ohio Northern |
Sr. | Chardon, Ohio |
| OF | Jake Craft |
Anderson |
Sr. | LaPorte, Ind. |
| OF | Christian Verde |
Heidelberg |
Sr. | Highland Heights, Ohio |
| DH | Hunter Handel |
Baldwin Wallace |
Jr. | Akron, Ohio |
| U | Nick Eltzroth |
Ohio Northern |
Jr. | Westerville, Ohio |
| SP | Christian Herstine |
Marietta |
Jr. | Beaver, Pa. |
| SP | Karson Nixon |
Rose-Hulman |
Jr. | Jasper, Ind. |
| SP | Brian Resnik |
Waynesburg |
Jr. | Burgettstown, Pa. |
| RP | Alec McNally |
Rose-Hulman |
Jr. | Geneva, Ill. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Aaron Caputo |
Ohio Wesleyan |
Jr. | Strongsville, Ohio |
| 1B | Trent Smith |
Thiel |
Jr. | Franklin, Pa. |
| 2B | Zach Gray |
Allegheny |
Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| SS | Trevor Kimm |
Manchester |
Sr. | Anderson, Ind. |
| 3B | Jordan Nieman |
Manchester |
Sr. | Michigan City, Ind. |
| OF | Connor Bowie |
Mount Aloysius |
Jr. | Ancaster, Ontario |
| OF | Jeff Gertley |
Adrian |
Jr. | Northville, Mich. |
| OF | Grant Van Putten |
Calvin |
Sr. | Holland, Mich. |
| DH | Devin Van Winkle |
Ohio Wesleyan |
So. |
Plain City, Ohio |
| U | Matt Elko |
Thiel |
Jr. | Middlefield, Ohio |
| SP | Jordan Frayer |
Adrian |
Jr. | New Boston, Mich. |
| SP | Riley Groves |
Washington and Jefferson |
So. |
Louisville, Ohio |
| SP | Tanner Wilt |
La Roche |
Jr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| RP | Matt Brankle |
Earlham |
Sr. | Kokomo, Ind. |