Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Connor Bertsch, 1B, Jr., Concordia (Texas)
Pitcher of the Year: Taylor Henry, Sr., Centenary (La.)
Rookie of the Year: Justin Traxler, RP, Concordia (Texas)
Coach of the Year: Tim Scannell, Trinity (Texas)
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Joshua Davis |
Whitworth |
Sr. | Santa Rosa Valley, Calif. |
| 1B | Connor Bertsch |
Concordia (Texas) |
Jr. | Fayetteville, Texas |
| 2B | Colin Serkowski |
Trinity (Texas) |
Jr. | Richland, Wash. |
| SS | Sam Fox |
Pomona-Pitzer |
Sr. | New York, N.Y. |
| 3B | Brandon George |
Texas-Dallas |
Jr. | Spring, Texas |
| OF | Ramsey Abushahla | Cal Lutheran |
Jr. | Woodland Hills, Calif. |
| OF | Will Cates | Southwestern |
Jr. | Cy Fair, Texas |
| OF | Jeremy Wolf | Trinity (Texas) | Jr. | Scottsdale, Ariz. |
| DH | Robert Loewe | Mary Hardin-Baylor |
Sr. | Waller, Texas |
| U | Eli Gallego | Sul Ross State |
Jr. | Alpine, Texas |
| SP | Cameron Cox | Concordia (Texas) | Sr. | Round Rock, Texas |
| SP | Ryan Gray | Trinity (Texas) | Jr. | Tucson, Ariz. |
| SP | Chris Haddeland | Linfield |
Sr. | McMinnville, Ore. |
| RP | Taylor Henry |
Centenary (La.) |
Sr. | Bossier City, La. |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Buddy McCoy |
Texas-Tyler |
Sr. |
Haughton, La. |
| 1B | Tiras Koon |
Willamette |
Sr. |
Honolulu, Hawaii |
| 2B | Chris Zerio |
Puget Sound |
Jr. |
Pleasanton, Calif. |
| SS | Corey Vandomelen |
Linfield |
Sr. | Tigard, Ore. |
| 3B | Tyler Cook |
Chapman |
Jr. | Tustin, Calif. |
| OF | Jeremy Druffel |
Whitworth |
Jr. | Pullman, Wash. |
| OF | Tony Gennusa |
Texas Lutheran |
Sr. | Kingwood, Texas |
| OF | Collin Nilson |
Pacific Lutheran | Sr. | Milton, Wash. |
| DH | Collin Crowl |
Cal Lutheran |
Sr. | Council Bluffs, Iowa |
| U | Jake Bruml |
Pomona-Pitzer |
Sr. | San Mateo, Calif. |
| SP | Aaron Aleman |
Texas Lutheran |
Sr. | Corpus Christi, Texas |
| SP | Jaime Paxton |
Texas-Tyler |
Sr. | Hurst, Texas |
| SP | Dan Scheibe |
Whitworth |
Sr. | Richland, Wash. |
| RP | AJ Konopaski |
Pacific Lutheran | Sr. | Port Angeles, Wash. |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Sean McMillan |
Redlands |
Sr. | Redwood City, Calif. |
| 1B | Simon Rosenbaum |
Pomona-Pitzer |
Jr. | Los Altos Hills, Calif. |
| 2B | Landon Packard |
Pacific Lutheran | So. |
Puyallup, Wash. |
| SS | Andrew Beck |
University of the Ozarks |
So. | Conway, Ark. |
| 3B | Kyle Sanchez |
Cal Lutheran |
So. | Valencia, Calif. |
| OF | Devon DeRaad |
Occidental | So. | Scottsdale, Ariz. |
| OF | Tanner Nishioka |
Pomona-Pitzer |
So. | Honolulu, Hawaii |
| OF | Zach Rapacz |
George Fox |
Sr. | West Richland, Wash. |
| DH | Kevan House |
Texas-Tyler |
Sr. | Whitehouse, Texas |
| U | Mark Jebbia |
La Verne |
Sr. | Arcadia, Calif. |
| SP | Aaron Barteau |
Mary Hardin-Baylor |
Jr. |
Dallas, Texas |
| SP | Chris Bishop |
Pacific Lutheran |
Sr. | Rochester, Wash. |
| SP | Justin Jenkins |
Le Tourneau |
Sr. | Hallsville, Texas |
| RP | Justin Traxler |
Concordia (Texas) | Fr. |
Austin, Texas |