Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Marty Windisch, UTIL, Sr., McDaniel
Pitcher of the Year: Felix Baez, SP, Sr., Keystone
Rookie of the Year: Trey Hinkle, SP, Centenary (N.J.)
Coach of the Year: Jaime Shevchik, Keystone
| First Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Zach Leone | Susquehanna | So. | Pelham, N.Y. |
| 1B | Louis Reyes | Keystone | Sr. | Port St. Lucie, Fla. |
| 2B | Joe Venturino | Ramapo | Sr. | Barnegat Light, N.J. |
| 3B | Robbie Lynch | Manhattanville | Jr. | Bronx, N.Y. |
| SS | Justin Taylor | Lancaster Bible | Jr. | Greenville, S.C. |
| OF | Justin Cassinelli | Susquehanna | Sr. | Valhalla, N.Y. |
| OF | Patrick Roberts | TCNJ | Sr. | Hillsborough, N.J. |
| OF | Chris Triano | Keystone | Jr. | Greenwich, Conn. |
| DH | Joe Grato | Eastern | Sr. | Madison, N.J. |
| U | Marty Windisch | McDaniel | Sr. | Manchester, Md. |
| SP | Felix Baez | Keystone | Sr. | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| SP | Zach Kronick | McDaniel | Sr. | Schenectady, N.Y. |
| SP | Steven Ridings | Messiah | Sr. | Harwood, Md. |
| RP | Taylor Parsons | Montclair State | So. | Livingston, N.J. |
| Second Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Cameron Bahr | McDaniel | Sr. | Southampton, N.J. |
| 1B | Cameron Coons | Alvernia | Jr. | Gansevoort, N.Y. |
| 2B | Kyle Fackler | Elizabethtown | Jr. | Harrisburg, Pa. |
| 3B | Bryan Palsi | Susquehanna | Sr. | Brielle, N.J. |
| SS | Conor Reynolds | Johns Hopkins | Jr. | Baltimore, Md. |
| OF | Mike Abate | William Paterson | Jr. | Wayne, N.J. |
| OF | Angelo Kelly | Eastern | Jr. | Royersford, Pa. |
| OF | Caleb Lang | Cairn | Sr. | Batavia, N.Y. |
| DH | Sal Taormina | Kean | Sr. | Brooklyn, N.Y. |
| U | Chris Amato | Kean | Sr. | Wayne, N.J. |
| SP | Jesse Arnold | Keystone | Sr. | Stuart, Fla. |
| SP | Andrew Fisher | King’s | Sr. | Cherry Hill, N.J. |
| SP | Justin Herring | Haverford | So. | Douglassville, Pa. |
| RP | Jerry D’Andrea | Ramapo | So. | Ridgewood, N.J. |
| Third Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Cody MacNair | Neumann | So. | Cinnaminson, N.J. |
| 1B | Joe Champi | Wilkes | So. | Dupont, Pa. |
| 2B | Raul Shah | Johns Hopkins | Sr. | Ellicott City, Md. |
| 3B | Andy Lopez | Kean | Sr. | Jackson, N.J. |
| SS | K.C. Abel | William Paterson | Sr. | Wayne, N.J. |
| OF | Bryan Baquer | Washington College | Sr. | Woodbridge, Va. |
| OF | Joe Brooks | Rutgers-Camden | Jr. | Blackwood, N.J. |
| OF | D.J. Navoczynski | Misericordia | Sr. | Scranton, Pa. |
| DH | Garen Turner | TCNJ | Sr. | Hainesport, N.J. |
| U | Ryan MacFarlane | Rutgers-Newark | Sr. | Freehold, N.J. |
| SP | Trey Hinkle | Centenary (N.J.) | Fr. | Macungie, Pa. |
| SP | Josh Lafferty | Widener | So. | Pottstown, Pa. |
| SP | Sean Pavlik | Penn State-Berks | So. | Boyertown, Pa. |
| RP | Liam Conboy | Susquehanna | Jr. | Old Tappan, N.J. |