Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Mark Zimmerman, UTIL, Sr., Baldwin Wallace
Pitcher of the Year: Christian Herstine, SP, Sr., Marietta
Rookie of the Year: Walter Talcott, SP, Earlham
Coach of the Year: Chase Rowe, La Roche
| First Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Aaron Caputo | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Strongsville, Ohio |
| 1B | Ben Herstine | La Roche | Jr. | Beaver, Pa. |
| 2B | Caleb Kissel | Rose-Hulman | Sr. | Plainfield, Ill. |
| 3B | Joe Killian | Allegheny | Sr. | Springdale, Pa. |
| SS | Ryan Dorow | Adrian | Jr. | South Haven, Mich. |
| OF | Tyler Kent | Otterbein | Sr. | Grove City, Ohio |
| OF | Ryan Konkle | Hope | Sr. | Marshall, Mich. |
| OF | Luis Navedo | La Roche | Jr. | Vega Alta, Puerto Rico |
| DH | Ben Legath | Mount Aloysius | Jr. | Johnstown, Penn. |
| U | Mark Zimmerman | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Akron, Ohio |
| SP | Christian Herstine | Marietta | Sr. | Beaver, Pa. |
| SP | Tommy Parsons | Adrian | So. | New Albany, Ohio |
| SP | Tanner Wilt | La Roche | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| RP | T.J. Storer | Ohio Northern | So. | Loveland, Ohio |
| Second Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Anthony Bozzuto | Pitt-Greensburg | Sr. | Greensburg, Pa. |
| 1B | Jaime Lackner | Wooster | Jr. | Westlake, Ohio |
| 2B | Ben Laumann | Thomas More | So. | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| 3B | Jack Clark | Kalamazoo | Jr. | Ann Arbor, Mich. |
| SS | Michael Wielansky | Wooster | Fr. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| OF | Michael Fischbach | Albion | Sr. | Valencia, Calif. |
| OF | Corey Lazor | La Roche | Jr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| OF | Jim Shomberg | Penn State-Altoona | So. | Lansdale, Pa. |
| DH | Steven Marowski | Albion | So. | Farmington Hills, Mich. |
| U | Matt Elko | Thiel | Sr. | Middlefield, Ohio |
| SP | Alec McNally | Rose-Hulman | Sr. | Geneva, Ill. |
| SP | Ryan Orr | Kalamazoo | So. | DeWitt, Iowa |
| SP | Walter Talcott | Earlham | Fr. | Lafayette, Ind. |
| RP | David Stover | Marietta | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| Third Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Dan Koller | Thiel | Sr. | Euclid, Ohio |
| 1B | Matt Waugaman | Grove City | Jr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| 2B | Scott Sada | Penn State-Behrend | Fr. | Saegertown, Pa. |
| 3B | Logan Bastin | Capital | Jr. | Mansfield, Ohio |
| SS | Justin Dages | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Green, Ohio |
| OF | Tim McCoy | Marietta | Sr. | Willoughby, Ohio |
| OF | Ian Mikowski | Adrian | Jr. | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| OF | Trey Simpson | Transylvania | Sr. | Louisville, Ky. |
| DH | Daniel Watson | Case Western Reserve | So. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| U | Nick Eltzroth | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Westerville, Ohio |
| SP | Chase Boyer | Allegheny | Jr. | Sandusky, Ohio |
| SP | Brian Resnik | Waynesburg | Sr. | Burgettstown, Pa. |
| SP | Regis Sauer | La Roche | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| RP | Ken Ruberg | Thomas More | Jr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |