Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Travis Lodge, 3B, Sr., Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: James Walsh, SP, Sr., Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Billy Dimlow, SP, Emory
Coach of the Year: Mike Twardoski, Emory
| First Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Adrian Celata | Oglethorpe | So. | Duluth, Ga. |
| 1B | Jake Dmiterchik | Salisbury | Sr. | Milton, Del. |
| 2B | K.J. Hockaday | Frostburg State | Sr. | Joppa, Md. |
| 3B | Travis Lodge | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Chesterfield, Va. |
| SS | Bill Munson | Rhodes | Jr. | Houston, Texas |
| OF | Devin Bell | Frostburg State | Jr. | Walkersville, Md. |
| OF | Kenner Berry | Bridgewater (Va.) | Jr. | Mechanicsville, Va. |
| OF | Tommy Vitaletti | Christopher Newport | Sr. | Williamsburg, Va. |
| DH | Jake Loew | Shenandoah | Jr. | Binghamton, N.Y. |
| U | Pete Grasso | Salisbury | Jr. | Wilmington, Del. |
| SP | Ryan Gaines | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. | Dunwoody, Ga. |
| SP | Michael Scimanico | Shenandoah | Sr. | Dumont, N.J. |
| SP | James Walsh | Randolph-Macon | Sr. | Mechanicsville, Va. |
| RP | Kyle Monk | Emory | Jr. | Cortlandt Manor, N.Y. |
| Second Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Tom LaBriola | Salisbury | Jr. | Huntingtown, Md. |
| 1B | Zack Blonder | Maryville (Tenn.) | Sr. | Atlanta, Ga. |
| 2B | David Scott | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. | Atlanta, Ga. |
| 3B | Blake Butcher | LaGrange | Jr. | Watkinsville, Ga. |
| SS | Ciro Norzagaray | North Carolina Wesleyan | Sr. | Mexico City, Mexico |
| OF | Kyle Goodwin | Salisbury | Sr. | Salisbury, Md. |
| OF | Brandon Lineberry | Emory and Henry | Sr. | Hillsville, Ga. |
| OF | Sam Roberts | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. | Johns Creek, Ga. |
| DH | James Lovett | North Carolina Wesleyan | Sr. | West Palm Beach, Fla. |
| U | Ben Jernigan | Berry | Sr. | Atlanta, Ga. |
| SP | Jake Perkins | Ferrum | Sr. | Appomattox, Va. |
| SP | Greg Schneider | Frostburg State | So. | Jefferson Hills, Pa. |
| SP | Jackson Weeg | Emory | Jr. | Woodstock, Ga. |
| RP | Phil Morse | Shenandoah | Sr. | Vienna, Va. |
| Third Team |
||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | James Keller | Mary Washington | Sr. | Fredericksburg, Va. |
| 1B | Cain Sauls | LaGrange | Jr. | Carrollton, Ga. |
| 2B | Drew Judson | Hendrix | So. | Austin, Texas |
| 3B | Taylor McCracken | Birmingham-Southern | Sr. | Oxford, Ala. |
| SS | Tavin Thompson | LaGrange | Jr. | Hogansville, Ga. |
| OF | Abel Arocho | Shenandoah | Jr. | Glen Burnie, Md. |
| OF | Patrick Kucera | Huntingdon | Sr. | Robertsdale, Ala. |
| OF | Alex Rodriguez | Methodist | Sr. | Walkersville, Md. |
| DH | Brian Hernandez | Emory | Jr. | Miami, Fla. |
| U | Rick Spiers | Randolph-Macon | So. | South Chesterfield, Va. |
| SP | Tom Concklin | Washington and Lee | Jr. | Hinsdale, Ill. |
| SP | Hans Hansen | Emory | Jr. | Playa del Rey, Calif. |
| SP | Stephen Himic | Birmingham-Southern | Jr. | Birmingham, Ala. |
| RP | Nick Huff | Frostburg State | Sr. | Waldorf, Md. |