Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Ian Mikowski, OF, Sr., Adrian
Pitcher of the Year: Phil Mary, SP, So., Mount Union
Rookie of the Year: Pierce Banks, SP, Adrian
Coach of the Year: Tim Pettorini, Wooster
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Derek Helbing | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Pataskala, Ohio |
| 1B | Jamie Lackner | Wooster | Sr. | Westlake, Ohio |
| 2B | Brian Killinger | Adrian | Sr. | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| SS | Ryan Dorow | Adrian | Sr. | South Haven, Mich. |
| 3B | Ian Velez | La Roche | Sr. | Rockville, Md. |
| OF | Billy Goodall | Mount Union | Jr. | Canfield, Ohio |
| OF | Ian Kobernick | Kalamazoo | Sr. | Huntington Woods, Mich. |
| OF | Ian Mikowski | Adrian | Sr. | Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| DH | Mitchell Yard | La Roche | Sr. | Saltsburg, Pa. |
| UT | Ryan Orr | Kalamazoo | Jr. | DeWitt, Mich. |
| SP | Riley Groves | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Louisville, Ohio |
| SP | Phil Mary | Mount Union | So. | Venetia, Pa. |
| SP | Tommy Parsons | Adrian | Jr. | New Albany, Ohio |
| RP | T.J. Storer | Ohio Northern | Jr. | Loveland, Ohio |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Monroe Donnelly |
John Carroll |
Jr. | Charlotte, N.C. |
| 1B | David Lemley | La Roche | Sr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| 2B | Scott Sada | Penn State-Behrend | So. | Saegertown, Pa. |
| SS | Michael Wielansky | Wooster | So. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| 3B | Frank Fortunato | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Canonsburg, Pa. |
| OF | Jake Fling | Wooster | Jr. | Norton, Ohio |
| OF | Jack Thompson | DePauw | Sr. | Carmel, Ind. |
| OF | Nick Vento | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Murrysville, Pa. |
| DH | Cole Nieto | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Brunswick, Ohio |
| UT | Mike Hammel | DePauw | Sr. | Westfield, Ind. |
| SP | Pierce Banks | Adrian | Fr. | Sterling Heights, Mich. |
| SP | Jordan Clark | Franklin | So. | Connersville, Ind. |
| SP | Craig Prince | Otterbein | Jr. | Hanover, Ohio |
| RP | Caleb Norton |
Otterbein | Sr. | Lima, Ohio |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Ryan Bonafede | Hilbert | Sr. | Cheektowaga, N.Y. |
| 1B | Tyler Holland | Pitt-Greensburg | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| 2B | Ben Laumann | Thomas More | Jr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| SS | Matthew McCourt | Mount Aloysius | So. | Mullica, N.J. |
| 3B | Zach Trusk | Rose-Hulman | Sr. | Plainfield, Ill. |
| OF | Corey Lazor | La Roche | Sr. | Bethel Park, Pa. |
| OF | Nate Lynch | Earlham | Sr. | Oxford, Ohio |
| OF | Luis Navedo | La Roche | Sr. | Vega Alta, Puerto Rico |
| DH | Bryan Stopar | Otterbein | Jr. | Westerville, Ohio |
| UT | Joseph Salmen | Westminster (Pa.) | Jr. | New Castle, Pa. |
| SP | Michael Houdek | Wooster | Sr. | Cleveland Heights, Ohio |
| SP | Nanak Saran | Wooster | Jr. | Hudson, Ohio |
| SP | Howie Smith | Earlham | Sr. | Hamilton, Ohio |
| RP | Ken Ruberg | Thomas More | Sr. | Cincinnati, Ohio |