Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Kyle Bonicki, SS, Jr., Clark
Pitcher of the Year: Speros Varinos, SP, Jr., Tufts
Rookie of the Year: Patrick Maybach, SP, Salve Regina
Coach of the Year: Brendan Eygabroat, Mass.-Boston
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Matt Brenner |
Suffolk | Sr. |
Eliot, Maine |
| 1B | Chris Fowler |
Mass-Boston |
Jr. |
Barnstable, Mass. |
| 2B | Kyle Hartenstein | Mitchell |
Jr. |
Meriden, Conn. |
| SS | Kyle Bonicki | Clark |
Jr. |
Waterbury, Conn. |
| 3B | Taylor Black | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Sr. |
Cardiff by the Sea, Calif. |
| OF | Brady Chant | Suffolk | Jr. |
Warwick, R.I. |
| OF | Dylan Hapworth | Southern Maine | Fr. |
Winslow, Maine |
| OF | Alex Zachary | Eastern Connecticut |
Sr. |
Enfield, Conn. |
| DH | Ryan Arena |
Babson | Jr. |
Yorktown Heights, N.Y. |
| U | Teddy Downing | Clark |
Jr. |
Cambridge, Mass. |
| SP | Patrick Maybach |
Salve Regina | Fr. |
Saunderstown, R.I. |
| SP | Speros Varinos |
Tufts | Sr. |
Middleton, Mass. |
| SP | Ben Walls | Husson |
Sr. |
Bar Harbor, Maine |
| RP | Jake Dexter | Southern Maine | So. |
Oakland, Maine |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Christian Vargas | Salve Regina | Jr. |
Melbourne, Fla. |
| 1B | Nick Falkson |
Tufts |
Jr. |
Dedham, Mass. |
| 2B | Josh Lopez | Mass-Boston | Jr. |
New Haven, Conn. |
| SS | Austin Filiere |
MIT | Jr. |
Chandler, Ariz. |
| 3B | Kyle Boudrias |
Mass-Boston | So. |
Medford, Mass. |
| OF | Anthony Crowley | Westfield State | So. |
Bellingham, Mass. |
| OF | Evan Delaney | New England College | So. | Hadley, Mass. |
| OF | Matt Johnston | MIT | Fr. |
Portola Valley, Calif. |
| DH | Adam Chochrek |
Clark | Sr. |
Foxboro, Mass. |
| U | Brandon Lopez |
Bowdoin | So. |
Amesbury, Mass. |
| SP | Chuck Gibson | Suffolk | Sr. |
Malden, Mass. |
| SP | John Lamont | Williams | Fr. | Groton, Mass. |
| SP | Davis Mikell |
Castleton | Fr. |
Williston, Vt. |
| RP | Will Bryant | Endicott | So. |
Cumberland, Maine |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Team | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Sam Huston |
Husson | So. |
Bangor, Maine |
| 1B | Jack Halpin |
Babson |
Sr. |
Glastonbury, Conn. |
| 2B | Chris Collins |
Hamilton | Sr. |
Weston, Conn. |
| SS | Garet Griffin |
Mitchell | Jr. |
Moosup, Conn. |
| 3B | Steven Gallagher |
WPI | So. |
Coventry, R.I. |
| OF | Connor Longley | Keene State | So. | Foxboro, Mass. |
| OF | Jake Ryan | Worcester State | Sr. |
Northbridge, Mass. |
| OF | Yanni Thanopoulos | Amherst | Sr. | Highland, Calif. |
| DH | Jameson Collins | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Sr. |
Sandown, N.H. |
| U | Hector Coscione |
Lasell |
Sr. |
Newton, Mass. |
| SP | Kevin Connelly | Framingham State | So. |
Bolton, Mass. |
| SP | Kevin Gould | Endicott | So. | Rollinsford, N.H. |
| SP | Bob Hamel | Western New England | So. |
Southwick, Mass. |
| RP | Josh Partridge | St. Joseph's (Maine) | Jr. |
Deerfield, N.H. |
Coach: Brendan Eygabroat