Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Brett Carson, Gr., UTL, Marietta
Pitcher of the Year: Matthew Aukerman, Sr., SP, John Carroll
Rookie of the Year: Ryar Rinehart, 3B, Kalamazoo
Coach of the Year: Mike Ott, Kalamazoo
First Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jack Anderson | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Clarkston, Mich. |
| 1B | Avery Carnicom | Alma | Sr. | Woodhaven, Mich. |
| 2B | Eli Westrick | Wooster | Jr. | Ashland, Ore. |
| SS | Joe Olsavsky | John Carroll | Jr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| 3B | Ryar Rinehart | Kalamazoo | Fr. | Rockford, Mich. |
| OF | Brett Carson | Marietta | Gr. | Ashville, Ohio |
| OF | Eric Colaco | Denison | So. | Richfield, Ohio |
| OF | Thomas Evans | Hilbert | Jr. | Orchard Park, N.Y. |
| DH | Edwin Groff | Kenyon | So. | Los Angeles, Calif. |
| UTL | Tyler Horvat | Wash. & Jeff. | Sr. | Irwin, Pa. |
| SP | Matthew Aukerman | John Carroll | Sr. | Hudson, Ohio |
| SP | Charlie Fleming | Denison | Sr. | Upper Arlington, Ohio |
| SP | Jack Hutchins | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Bright, Ind. |
| RP | Brendan Walsh | Hilbert | Jr. | Depew, N.Y. |
Second Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Charlie Glennon | Denison | Sr. | New Rochelle, N.Y. |
| 1B | Nick Serce | Alfred St. | Sr. | Irondequoit, N.Y. |
| 2B | Alex Richter | Marietta | So. | Carmel, Ind. |
| SS | Brayden Quincel | Otterbein | Jr. | Grove City, Ohio |
| 3B | Mally Kilbane | Grove City | So. | Olmsted Falls, Ohio |
| OF | James Domer | Pitt.-Greensburg | Fr. | Connellsville, Pa. |
| OF | Conor O'Malley | Wittenberg | Jr. | Avon, Ohio |
| OF | Tyler Quade | Mt. Aloysius | So. | Mechanicsville, Md. |
| DH | Alexis Castillo | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Sunrise, Fla. |
| UTL | Trent Valentine | Marietta | Sr. | Byesville, Ohio |
| SP | Blake Altaffer | Ohio Northern | So. | Montpelier, Ohio |
| SP | Nick Falter | Denison | So. | Powell, Ohio |
| SP | Tyler Johnson | Alma | So. | Lexington, Mich. |
| RP | Garrett Miller | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | McMurray, Pa. |
Third Team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Harrison Poeszat | Kalamazoo | Sr. | Commerce Twp., Mich. |
| 1B | Patrick Whelan | Hilbert | Sr. | Buffalo, N.Y. |
| 2B | Colton Stoneman | Bethany (W.V.) | Sr. | West Farmington, Ohio |
| SS | Patrick Gillen | Calvin | Fr. | Jensen Beach, Fla. |
| 3B | AJ Reid | Wabash | Jr. | Highland, Ind. |
| OF | Tyreke Green | Penn St.-Altoona | Sr. | Altoona, Pa. |
| OF | Nick Harms | Case Western Reserve | So. | St. Louis, Mo. |
| OF | Zachary Mazza | Mount Union | Sr. | Flint, Mich. |
| DH | Mac Ciocco | Penn St.-Behrend | So. | Venetia, Pa. |
| UTL | Ryan Davis | Adrian | So. | Hebron, Ohio |
| SP | Leo Fornara | Mount Union | Fr. | Chagrin Falls, Ohio |
| SP | Braden Mussat | Kalamazoo | Jr. | Troy, Mich. |
| SP | Tate Ostrowski | Grove City | Sr. | Essex, Mass. |
| RP | Caden Fortunato | Alfred St. | Fr. | Deposit, N.Y. |