Rankings fron April 26, 2023
Rankings are listed in each region by alphabetical order.
| Region 1 | vs. D3 | Overall |
| Amherst | 16-10-1 | 16-10-1 |
| Babson | 20-12 | 20-12 |
| Colby | 21-8 | 21-8 |
| Middlebury | 18-8 | 19-8 |
| Trinity (Conn.) | 17-11 | 17-11 |
| Tufts | 22-6 | 22-6 |
| Wheaton (Mass.) | 27-5 | 27-5 |
| Region 2 | ||
| Eastern Connecticut | 25-7 | 25-7 |
| Endicott | 26-5 | 26-5 |
| Mitchell | 27-6 | 27-6 |
| Rhode Island College | 22-11 | 22-11 |
| Salve Regina | 24-6-1 | 24-6-1 |
| Western New England | 20-7-2 | 20-7-2 |
| Region 3 | ||
| Brockport | 22-10 | 22-10 |
| Cortland | 23-9 | 23-9 |
| Ithaca | 20-12 | 20-12 |
| Rochester | 22-11 | 22-11 |
| St. John Fisher | 20-12 | 20-12 |
| St. Joseph's (L.I.) | 24-3 | 24-3 |
| SUNY Oneonta | 22-9 | 22-9 |
| Region 4 | ||
| Arcadia | 25-9 | 25-9 |
| Kean | 22-12-1 | 22-12-1 |
| Misericordia | 30-6 | 30-6 |
| Montclair State | 21-9 | 21-9 |
| Penn State-Harrisburg | 28-7 | 28-7 |
| Rowan | 24-10 | 24-10 |
| Region 5 | ||
| Catholic | 23-7 | 23-7 |
| Dickinson | 21-12-1 | 21-12-1 |
| Elizabethtown | 26-7 | 26-7 |
| Franklin & Marshall | 23-13 | 23-13 |
| Immaculata | 21-8 | 21-8 |
| Johns Hopkins | 32-3 | 32-3 |
| Salisbury | 26-4 | 26-4 |
| Region 6 | ||
| Birmingham-Southern | 31-9 | 31-9 |
| Christopher Newport | 30-7 | 30-7 |
| LaGrange | 25-11 | 25-11 |
| Lynchburg | 29-5 | 29-5 |
| North Carolina Wesleyan | 26-8 | 26-8 |
| Randolph-Macon | 28-8 | 28-8 |
| Shenandoah | 31-5 | 31-5 |
| Region 7 | ||
| Baldwin Wallace | 27-5 | 27-5 |
| Case Western Reserve | 22-12 | 22-12 |
| Denison | 25-7 | 25-7 |
| John Carroll | 21-11 | 21-11 |
| Marietta | 25-9 | 25-9 |
| Ohio Northern | 22-10 | 22-10 |
| Washington and Jefferson | 22-8 | 22-10 |
| Region 8 | ||
| Augustana | 26-6 | 26-6 |
| Aurora | 26-3 | 26-3 |
| Benedictine | 20-9 | 20-9 |
| North Central (Ill.) | 19-9 | 19-9 |
| Spalding | 23-9 | 23-9 |
| Washington U. | 25-12 | 25-12 |
| Webster | 20-12 | 20-12 |
| Region 9 | ||
| Bethel | 18-4 | 18-4 |
| Buena Vista | 27-6 | 27-6 |
| Luther | 20-13 | 20-13 |
| UW-La Crosse | 22-6 | 22-6 |
| UW-Oshkosh | 22-6 | 22-6 |
| UW-Stevens Point | 20-9 | 20-9 |
| UW-Whitewater | 17-11 | 17-11 |
| Region 10 | ||
| Chapman | 22-12 | 22-12 |
| Claremont-Mudd-Scripps | 24-7 | 24-7 |
| East Texas Baptist | 27-9 | 27-9 |
| La Verne | 23-11 | 23-11 |
| Lewis & Clark | 27-11 | 30-12 |
| Pacific | 23-11 | 23-12 |
| Southwestern | 23-8 | 23-10 |